Amy's Candy Kitchen is a Sweet Detour North of Milwaukee – Food review photo
Food
★★★★★★★★★★
Oct 2026 · 2 min read

Amy's Candy Kitchen is a Sweet Detour North of Milwaukee

By Kamal Hubbard ·

Location

Price

$$

Visited

2026-10-29

Would return?

Yes

The verdict

This Candy Shop is a Sweet Stop in Historic Cedarburg, Wisconsin

Historic Cedarburg, Wisconsin, just a short drive north of Milwaukee, is home to Amy’s Candy Kitchen, a destination that engages your senses before you even make your first purchase. Step inside, and the air greets you with an inviting mix of toasted marshmallows, buttery caramel, rich chocolate, and hints of toasted sugar. It is the kind of aroma that makes browsing feel like part of the experience. The staff are ready to answer questions, explain the confectionery selection, and offer samples when available. That personal touch makes it easier to explore unfamiliar treats and decide which sweets deserve a spot in your bag. Amy’s takes its craft seriously, particularly its award-winning caramel apples. Beyond those signature creations, the selection offers plenty to explore, from chocolate-dipped marshmallows to Belgian chocolate-covered toffee. Whether you gravitate toward classic candy-shop favorites or more indulgent chocolate treats, there is something to tempt nearly every sweet tooth. At 4.75 out of 5 stars, Amy’s Candy Kitchen earns a strong recommendation for candy apple enthusiasts, chocolate lovers, and anyone exploring Cedarburg’s historic downtown. Stop in, sample something new, and rediscover an old favorite. For visitors looking for distinctive Wisconsin confectionery and a memorable sweet stop near Milwaukee, this shop deserves a place on the itinerary.

Amy's Candy Kitchen is a Sweet Detour North of Milwaukee – Food review photo

Gallery

More like this